A Multiplication Based Logic Puzzle

194 is a composite number. Factor pairs: 194 = 1 x 194 or 2 x 97. Factors of 194: 1, 2, 97, 194. Prime factorization: 194 = 2 x 97.

Are multiplication rhymes able to help kids learn the multiplication table? The obvious answer is, of course, YES! Duh!

Little Pigs Multiplication Rhymes

However, sometimes this obvious answer may not be correct. I recently read a researched article on the effectiveness of certain teaching practices in helping first grade children learn mathematics. The points made in the article would likely apply to third and fourth grade students learning multiplication as well. The article states that alternative techniques (music, movement, m&m’s, other manipulatives, etc.) do reinforce concepts for students who already understand what is being taught, but students who struggle actually make no gains when unproven techniques are used. The researcher hypothesized that when students struggle learning mathematical concepts “alternative techniques tend to demand more, cognitively, from [these] students.” Demanding more cognitively can backfire: Requiring a student to memorize a rhyme and the math fact could put that student’s brain on overload with even less facts learned.

I have now modified my opinion of multiplication rhymes. If rhyme-and-rhythm is helpful, use it, if not, don’t. What is good for some of the class, may not be good for all of the class. If a student doesn’t make progress using the rhymes, it may be better to stick with more direct instruction to learn the math facts. Additionally, each rhyme should be examined individually and its own pros and cons considered.

Here are two of my FAVORITE sources of multiplication rhymes: American Academy’s MULTIPLICATION-RHYMES.pdf now requires registration to view, but it has rhymes printed in pretty colors and contains a few of my favorite multiplication rhymes. Kids would probably like looking at this pdf multiple times.

Multiplication Rhymes 1 is an entertaining You-tube video made by Mrs. Rice that children would probably enjoy watching over and over again, and it also has a few very memorable rhymes.

Mrs. Rice shares 4 x 4 = 16 rhyme.

Although these two sources are great, I think some of the rhymes are too similar:

  • From the pdf we have “8 and 4 were sad and blue, 8 x 4 = 32” while the video recites “6 and 7 are sad and blue, they make number 42.” If students learned either of those rhymes, they may have difficulty remembering the product or which two numbers were sad and blue several weeks later.
  • The video also gave two other rhymes that were too similar to each other: “9 and 8 what do they do? They go play (tag) with 72.” and  “9 and 9 are having fun. They play tag with 81.” “Tag” is in parentheses because it wasn’t on the note card that was shown, but it was spoken on the video. Again weeks later, groups or individuals may not remember which numbers were playing tag or what the product was when they were multiplied together.

I compiled my own List of Multiplication Rhymes which focus on the multiplication facts highlighted in the multiplication table below. I included some rhymes from the above pdf and the video and added some from the song Five Pennies Make a Nickel. All of those rhymes are in italics. The rhymes that I wrote myself are in regular print. If I modified an existing rhyme, the modifications are in regular print while the rest of the rhyme is in italics. I also ordered the rhymes in a way that should make finding the rhyme for any particular fact much easier. I hope there will be many rhymes on this list that you enjoy as well, and that they get used to help many students learn the very important multiplication facts highlighted in the table below.

Multiplication Rhymes Table

 Multiplication Rhymes

Advertisements

Comments on: "194 Are Multiplication Rhymes Able to Help Kids Learn the Multiplication Table?" (4)

  1. “If rhyme-and-rhythm is helpful, use it, if not, don’t. What is good for some of the class, may not be good for all of the class.”

    I love what you said here, and this very concept is part of why I love home schooling so, so much. If I see a technique isn’t working for Grace, I can quickly throw it in the garbage and try something different…a flexibility I sadly didn’t always have in an adminstation-driven classroom.

    Thanks for providing all of this information! 😀

    Like

  2. ivasallay said:

    You’re welcome!
    Grace is fortunate to have such an amazing and flexible teacher, too!

    Like

  3. My daughter had a hard time learning the times table.
    So I wrote an android application to assist her 🙂

    Each exercise kids solve helps them to feed the cute panda.
    You can get daily reminders to feed the panda (solve exercises) and kids get rewarded with trophies upon goals completion.

    Using this application my daughter learned the whole times table without noticing 🙂

    * Currently the application is only for Android phones *
    https://goo.gl/9QutZx

    Liked by 1 person

    • Apps take time and talent to develop, so you REALLY got involved in your daughter’s education! It’s wonderful that you are making it available for other children to learn from as well. Thanks for letting us know about it.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud